Photo: Luke Wolagiewicz/WPN; Kareem Raheem/Reuters
|
BOMB BUILDING 101: These Arabic-language Web sites offer how-to
tips on constructing homemade explosives. The
factual information is often sketchy, though.
|
In studying the behaviors of insurgencies in Iraq and
elsewhere, as well as organized-crime syndicates and
other groups, Robb noticed the many parallels to the
open-source model in software. In addition to working in
counterterrorism, he has also had a successful career as
a software entrepreneur.
Groups like al-Qaeda resemble in some ways the classic
insurgents of the past, such as the Palestine Liberation
Organization, but several factors distinguish them from
their predecessors, Robb says. For one, they aren't
state-sponsored, which makes them harder to track down
and eradicate. Being self-financed, they generate
significant income from donations as well as from
black-market commerce. Also, members of the group don't
report to a central authority; they operate relatively
autonomously, and they tend to be well educated,
media-savvy, and comfortable operating in a globalized,
high-tech world. And the use of information technology
has given modern terrorists an operational edge their
predecessors lacked.
Mimicking open-source developers, insurgent groups
“hack at the source code of warfare,” Robb says. By
that, he means they aren't bound by the traditional
rules of military engagement; they use whatever works,
with their tactics, techniques, and procedures all open
to scrutiny and improvement by the community. Although
such groups are weak by conventional military
benchmarks—they'd clearly be outgunned and outmanned
on an open battlefield—they can still threaten strong
national militaries. That's because they don't aim to
invade, hold, or govern territory, but rather to exert
political influence by exhausting an adversary's
capacity to fight back. Their preferred method of attack
is to disrupt infrastructure, whether physical,
financial, or political [see photos, “World at War”].
“System disruption is going to be the main thrust of
warfare for quite a long time,” Robb predicts.
Rand CORP.'s
Jackson has also studied terrorist
organizations with an eye toward how they learn and
share information—which he discussed in a recent report
titled “Aptitude for Destruction.” Access to the
Internet, Jackson says, has given such groups “a quantum
leap in capability to get their message out.”
Many of the insurgent groups in Iraq, he notes, “are
very Internet-savvy in terms of using it as an
information-dissemination medium.” The number of Web
sites run by terrorists climbed from fewer than a dozen
in 1997 to nearly 5000 in mid-2006, according to Gabriel
Weimann, a professor of communications at the University
of Haifa, in Israel, who has studied terrorism and the
mass media. Not all of those sites pose a significant
threat. Last year, a team of Pentagon analysts told
Congress that of the thousands of jihadist sites they
monitor, they closely watch fewer than 100—the ones
they deem the most hostile.
Whereas the mass media used to control access to the
public, Jackson says, insurgents now post videos and
descriptions of their attacks online within hours of
their occurrence, many of which are then picked up and
replayed in the global media. Al‑Qaeda has a media
affiliate that produces slick, branded video and audio
files for online distribution. The videos are often
encoded in multiple formats, so you can watch them on
your cellphone or play them on a big-screen television.
Some insurgents are even shooting in HDTV.
Terrorist Web sites serve not only to spread
propaganda but also to share knowledge among insurgent
groups, Jackson says. That helps explain why the
learning cycles among Iraqi insurgents are some 20 times
as fast as the Irish Republican Army's were in Northern
Ireland in the 1980s, according to military estimates.
The SITE Institute, a group in Washington, D.C., that
monitors terrorist Web activities, has documented
numerous cases of technical know-how being exchanged
online. These include a slide presentation posted on a
password-protected Arabic-language forum purporting to
teach “beginner jihad fighters” how to rig a car bomb,
as well as a training manual—linked to from various
jihadist forums—that claims to cover explosives,
poisons, and forgery, among other topics.
To be sure, the technical information that goes up on
such sites is not always to be trusted, notes Michael
Kenney, an assistant professor of public policy at
Pennsylvania State University in Harrisburg. “Some of
the terrorist instructional manuals and online chat
rooms that have received so much attention in the press
are, in fact, littered with basic mistakes,” Kenney
says. He had one of the world's leading explosives
experts review some online training manuals. The expert
found that “for every four or five recipes, one may
work, [but] only a trained eye can catch” the errors,
Kenney says.