14 May 2008—This month’s most surprising merger story
isn’t the one that failed (Microsoft-Yahoo);
it’s the one that succeeded, against all odds.
Sprint-Nextel, the No. 3 U.S. cellular company, merged
its nascent
fourth-generation network, called Xohm,
with that of Clearwire, a small wireless carrier in the
Pacific Northwest.
The new entity, which will be majority owned by
Sprint but called Clearwire, joins two entities that
rely on the same technology but haven’t agreed on much
else; a planned joint operating agreement fell apart
last autumn. It’s as if a couple who couldn’t agree
where to spend a vacation decided to get married
instead. At least the happy couple will have a nice
honeymoon, with a US $3.2 billion dowry given jointly by
Intel, Google, three cable companies, and an investment
firm (see sidebar “”).
The deal should put to rest many of Wall Street’s
concerns about Sprint’s ambitious plan to cover the
nation with WiMax, a
form of wireless broadband that’s based on the IEEE
802.16 standard and which offers mobile
data speeds of 2 to 4 megabits per second. Back in
October, shareholders forced the resignation of CEO Gary
Forsee, in part due to poor subscriber retention but
also because of the investment needed to build the
Xohm network. Forsee planned to spend $3
billion to cover 70 million people in
the nation’s largest cities by the end
of 2008. (The earlier Sprint-Clearwire
operating agreement would have added another 30 million
people.)
The dowry should free the new Clearwire from many of
Xohm’s financial troubles. It also resolves questions
about an open-ended plan that would have let cable
operators to use Sprint’s network to
sell a cellular service to their
existing customers. Back in 2006, Sprint had
forged an agreement in principle with the four leading
U.S. cable providers: Comcast, Time Warner, Cox, and
Advance/Newhouse. At the time, they were responding to
moves by the major telephone companies to build video
services that could compete with the meat and potatoes
of the cable business—the delivery of television
programming. Since then, Verizon and AT&T, by far
the United States’ largest telcos, have begun to sell
what analysts call, with tongue-in-cheek, the
“four-play” of television, broadband, residential
telephony, and cellular telephony.
The new deal includes three of the cable companies
involved in the 2006 agreement (Bright House Networks is
owned by Advance/Newhouse). Cox, which took advantage of
the recent 700-megahertz auction to add to some existing
wireless spectrum holdings, seems to have decided to go
it alone.
Besides selling the four-play, any of the three
participating cable companies could simply resell
Clearwire’s service under its own name, creating what is
known as a “mobile virtual network operator,” or MVNO.
Sprint already sells its current voice service to a
number of MVNOs, including Virgin Mobile and Qwest, the
lone incumbent telco in the United States without a
cellular service of its own. A cableco MVNO could create
a certain amount of confusion for customers, who would
be able to buy the same wireless service directly from
the new Clearwire. But the Clearwire deal also opens the
door to more than just mobile telephony.