Someday, millions of
cars will come off assembly lines as
hybrids. Analysts are mostly agreed on that. But for
now, in the whole wide world fewer than 200 PHEVs roam
the roads. Plug-in conversions are a cottage industry in
North America, offered in kit or turnkey form by perhaps
a dozen businesses and organizations. Over the past two
years, the budding industry has been aided and abetted
by a remarkable and vocal network of plug-in owners,
advocates, and fans. They swamp Internet bulletin boards
and e-mail their government representatives, arguing for
a vast R&D effort aimed at producing cars that get
100 miles per gallon or more, powered as much as
possible by grid electricity. The key enabler is recent
advances in large-format lithium-ion batteries [see
“Lithium
Batteries Take to the Road,” IEEE
Spectrum, September 2007].
One influential advocacy group is the California Cars
Initiative, a Palo Alto–based nonprofit start-up of
entrepreneurs, engineers, environmentalists, and
consumers. CalCars maintains a popular wiki on all
topics having to do with plug‑in hybrids, particularly
public policy and technology developments
(http://www.calcars.org). By stirring
demand, the organization hopes to “encourage automakers
to produce 100+ MPG ‘no-sacrifices’ high-performance,
clean hybrid cars,” to quote its mission statement. Or
as Carl Lawrence, lead founder and CEO of converter
Hybrids Plus, says, “It’s about creating the perception
that this can be done—that if you’re not talking 60 or
80 miles per gallon, then you’re wasting your time.”
It’s quite a big tent of proponents, with some of them
worried more about national security than ecology. R.
James Woolsey Jr., former director of the CIA, told an
IEEE symposium last fall that he views plug-ins as one
way to help “destroy oil as a strategic commodity.”
Right now, though, if you want a plug-in, converting
an existing conventional hybrid-electric vehicle is the
only way to go. It will be three years or more before
any of the major automakers sells a car designed from
the ground up as a PHEV. Even then, the industry will
most likely have to subsidize the cost of the battery
packs for years. It’s widely assumed that Toyota has
subsidized its hybrid vehicles, which make up almost 80
percent of the hybrids sold worldwide since the
first-generation Prius was introduced in 1997.
The second-generation
Prius, introduced in 2003, is the
highest-volume hybrid vehicle ever made. Toyota has now
built more than half a million of them. Last year, the
company sold 181 221 Priuses in the United States alone;
the model’s distinctive wedge profile suggests “hybrid
car” the same way the distinctive radiator shell of a
Rolls-Royce intones “luxury.” The Prius also makes a
surprisingly good PHEV, considering that it was never
intended to be one. And to explain why, we’ll start by
tearing apart a stock Prius.
Toyota’s Hybrid Synergy Drive system seamlessly
shuffles power among the combustion engine, two electric
motor-generators, and a battery pack. The main
50-kilowatt (67‑horsepower) motor-generator does just
one thing: it drives the front wheels through a
reduction gear, which reduces the motor-generator’s
rotational speed to the wheels’ lower speed. The
secondary motor-generator serves several masters. It
recharges the 1.3-kilowatt-hour nickel-metal-hydride
(NiMH) battery pack, and it supplements the power from
the main electric motor when more propulsion is needed.
The secondary motor-generator also quickly starts the
gas engine. To save fuel, the Prius, like most
conventional hybrids, shuts off its gasoline engine
whenever the car is not in motion—for example, at a
stoplight—and then restarts it when the car gets back up
to about 25 km/h or whenever the driver steps down hard
on the accelerator.
The mechanism by which the system shuffles power, and
the heart of Hybrid Synergy Drive, is known as a
planetary gear set. In this set, a central gear (the
sun”) connects to the drive shaft of the secondary
motor-generator. Its “planet” gears are in turn
surrounded by a ring gear that drives, or is driven by,
the main motor-generator—which is also connected to the
differential that turns the wheels. The carrier for the
planet gears is connected to the engine’s output shaft.
By varying the speed at which the planet gears spin,
this arrangement allows the system’s control software to
alter the power split between primary and secondary
motor-generators. More speed means more power going to
the main motor. All three components—the ring gear, the
planetary carrier, and the sun gear—work in unison to
control the torque output through the ring gear to the wheels.
In a Prius, then, engine power may either turn the
wheels or recharge the battery pack. The car’s control
software makes those decisions, splitting motive power
between engine and electric motors, recharging, and
regenerating power on braking.