Some days in the
desert are better than others. Even for
robots. Just a few weeks earlier, Zoë had a very bad
day. The field team had to transport the robot by truck
from Site D, on Chile's northern coast, to Site E, at
Salar de Navidad to the south, about 400 km away over
rough roads. They had the option of disassembling the
robot, as they do when shipping it between Pittsburgh
and Chile. But that requires several days of reassembly
afterward, so instead, they loaded the fully assembled
robot into the truck, secured it to the walls, placed
wooden pallets underneath it to cushion the bumps, and
hoped for the best. When they arrived at Site E,
however, they discovered that the pallets had shaken
loose and that Zoë's front axle had buckled and the rear
axle had fractured completely. Several instruments,
including the onboard spectrometer and the pan-tilt
camera, also took a beating.
"My suspicion is that the wood underneath shifted and
the robot basically started hopping up and down in the
back of the truck," Wettergreen says. "The stresses on
its axles would have been at least an order of magnitude
greater than it would normally experience when it's
driving."
Fortunately, the team had a spare set of axles in
Pittsburgh. Jonak, the software engineer, was scheduled
to travel to Chile anyway, so he loaded the spares into
a ski bag and brought them down. Within the week, the
robot was reassembled and nearly as good as new. Just to
be sure, though, when it came time to move from Site E
to Site F, the engineers seated the robot on a bed of
rubber tires; no further mishap occurred.
Looking back, Wettergreen likes to think of it as an
"extreme experiment." There's an entire discipline
"where you test to the point of failure, basically," he
says and gives a rueful smile. "So we did that."
Compared with the axle
mishap, the various breakdowns, glitches, and
bugs that occur on a daily basis seem fairly pedestrian.
For example, Sols 2 and 3 at Site F bring a battery
problem that necessitates temporarily swapping out the
lithium-polymer packs for the spare lead-acid batteries;
several software problems, which cause the robot to fail
to execute part of its science plan and throw off the
navigation cameras for a spell; a problem with the
pan-tilt camera that causes the azimuth to slip and
requires the entire camera unit to be dismounted,
leaving Zoë decapitated for a time; and, perhaps most
troubling of all, a lunch problem, caused by a shortage
of bread back at camp. In place of the usual
ham-and-cheese sandwiches, the cook sends a plastic bag
of apples, oranges, and bananas; the field team grimly
accepts the proffered fruits.
Often problems arise out of the best of intentions.
Explaining the camera's software glitch, Jonak says,
"There's kind of a black art to stereo calibration. You
need to fiddle around with things so it's just so, and
you're never really totally satisfied that you have the
best system...you can always make these minor
improvements. Unfortunately, that got us into trouble,
because we tried to improve things, and we ended up
knocking something out of whack."
In between repairs on Sols 2, 3, and 4, the robot
fits in quite a bit of science and executes a few
traverses of several kilometers. "We're traveling a lot
farther than last year, things are running a lot more
smoothly, and the [operations] are much more
autonomous," Jonak says. "Despite these mechanical
problems we've been having, we're still very happy with
the rover's performance."
"You just have to
embrace your filth." Wettergreen is
leaning back in his chair at dinner, grinning, and
trying in his own way to commiserate with a team member
who's complaining about the impossibility of staying
clean. It's the end of Sol 3, and we've all spent far
too long coated with a fine layer of dust. It's in every
pore and on every bit of hair, every garment. It's under
our fingernails, in the creases behind our ears, in the
folds of skin between our fingers.
Still, compared with the tents and sleeping bags at
the previous two sites, the dormitories at Site F seem
almost homey. The scientists still use sleeping bags,
but there are real mattresses here to put them on, and
the willful water heaters on occasion offer up a nice
hot shower. There's no heat, though, and as the
temperature plummets to below freezing at night,
layering on every scrap of clothing you've brought along
is the only way to keep warm.
But nobody would dream of missing the experience. "I
like the desert," says Roxana Wales, a research
scientist at NASA Ames Research Center, Moffett Field,
Calif. "I find it very calming." The team members also
get to experience things they won't soon forget. At Site
D, near the coast, recalls Trey Smith, a Ph.D. student
at Carnegie Mellon who worked on Zoë's software, "they
have these salt fogs that come over the mountains and
through the passes at sunset. Back in Pittsburgh when
it's foggy, the air is still. But here the fog just
races past you, like you're in a snow flurry. It's an
amazing effect."
While Zoë may
represent the next generation of planetary
rover, what about the next next generation—and the one
after that? "You're going to see a paradigm shift in
planetary exploration soon," predicts James Dohm, a
geologist at the University of Arizona, Tempe, and a
member of the science team. "Think about it: you have
vast areas that you need to cover. How are you going to
do that?" Ground-hugging robots like Zoë can cover at
most tens of kilometers a day. Aerial rovers, on the
other hand, could travel much farther, Dohm says. "In
the future we're going to see aerial robots as well as
fleets of ground-based rovers. That will be a golden age
for planetary exploration." Indeed, in December, NASA
announced a new competition to design and build an
autonomous aerial vehicle for conducting science
investigations on planets and moons that have
atmospheres. The competition, which ends in October
2007, carries a prize of $250 000.
Meanwhile, in January, project researchers convened
in Chile one last time. The itinerary called for a quick
visit to each of the six sites the robot had surveyed
during the last three years. For the scientists who'd
worked exclusively from Pittsburgh, it was the first
time they actually got to see the places in person,
rather than merely interpreting them through satellite
imagery, science data, or photos. "The scientists had a
great time, like kids in a candy store," Wettergreen
says. "Mostly they wanted to get the big picture—which
hill did the robot go over? Were we on that side or this
side of the drainage? I think the visit confirmed
everyone's expectations—they were happy they'd gotten
it right."