Out on the rocky
horizon, the robot has stopped dead in its tracks.
"Uh, Dave, I got a big problem out here," a voice
crackles over the radio.
"OK," David Wettergreen replies carefully, peering
off in the direction of the machine. "Define 'big.'"
"Big" turns out to be a new part for the robot that
doesn't quite fit and so prevents the robot's
cameras—its eyes—from turning properly. Back at the
laboratory, this would be a quick fix, but the robot,
Wettergreen, three geologists, two software engineers,
two sociologists, an electrical engineer, a mechanical
engineer, and a biologist are all out in the middle of
Chile's vast Atacama Desert, [see map] many hours' drive from
civilization.
As he strides off to investigate, you get the sense
Wettergreen's enjoying himself. For the better part of
an hour, he and two colleagues will wrestle with the
aberrant part [see photo, "All
in a Day's Work"]. The tedious work
produces the standard amount of swearing, but they also
joke—when one of them wields his drill stick-'em-up
style, Wettergreen gamely throws up his hands. Finally
they conclude that the job would be better handled back
at the base camp.
Wettergreen, an associate research professor at
Carnegie Mellon University's Robotics Institute, in
Pittsburgh, and his team have been roughing it here in
the Atacama since August, and they'll remain until
November, just as South America's spring gives way to
summer. They've come to test out new concepts and
designs for the next generation of planetary rover,
because this place, more than any other on Earth,
approximates the barren, arid rockiness of the Red
Planet. Testing the rover means pushing the technology
to its limits, and sometimes beyond. The robot is so
unusual and so new that breaking down is, for now,
anyway, what it's supposed to do. "A hundred percent
success means we're not really trying hard enough,"
Wettergreen says.
It isn't the
most elegant-looking machine ever built.
Weighing in at 180 kilograms, the rover, dubbed Zoë,
looks something like a motorized, overgrown ice cream
cart. But it is beautiful in the one way that really
matters to planetary scientists: unlike all the rovers
built thus far, Zoë can roam autonomously [see photo,
"Autopilot"].
Its lesser rover cousins still need human drivers back
on Earth to issue steady streams of commands that enable
the robots to pick their way gingerly among the
boulders, slopes, and ridges that constantly threaten to
trap or upend them; one false move could terminate an
interplanetary mission costing hundreds of millions of
dollars [see ""]. Zoë is smarter: it
can sense, among other things, when it's on an incline
of more than 30 degrees or nearing a too-precipitous
drop-off; in such situations, it is programmed to seek
an easier route.
The rover can even make some rudimentary decisions
about what terrain to explore. In a set of experiments
conducted in Chile, Zoë successfully determined which
tests to run at a given location. It started by taking
an initial image of the spot; based on the density and
types of rocks it was seeing, it calculated the
probability of finding life there. When it figured the
probability to be high enough, it ran through a sequence
of tests to look for chlorophyll; when it detected
chlorophyll, it went on to check for carbohydrates,
proteins, and other signs of life.
The calculations are all done with hardware that is
much less powerful than your typical desktop PC. All of
Zoë's six computers are off-the-shelf products designed
for factory automation, telecommunications, and other
industrial systems. Two 2.4-gigahertz Intel Pentium 4
processors control the robot's navigation and autonomy.
A computer based on an Advanced Micro Devices Celeron
chip estimates the robot's position, while an Intel
Pentium microprocessor looks after power management. Two
computers control the robot's motion.
The idea is that eventually, scientists back on Earth
won't need to send step-by-step instructions to the
robot; if it spots a rock of particular interest, it
will just mosey on over and investigate, instead of
waiting for a human to tell it what to do. A fully
autonomous rover is still a ways off, Wettergreen says.
In addition to making decisions about what instruments
to deploy or what tests to run, such a machine also will
need to consider the overall picture. If I veer off in
this direction to explore that patch of ground, how much
power will I consume? How long can I spend on the task
without compromising other activities? And so on.
"The simple things will happen first, maybe even in
the next generation of rovers," Wettergreen says. "But
it will be a long time before we see complex behaviors
showing up in flight systems."
Wettergreen and his team built Zoë with a US $3.9
million grant from NASA, and they've come to the Atacama
to see how well the rover copes with the kind of terrain
its successors will find on Mars. At Zoë's top speed of
1.2 meters per second, its human "wranglers," who trail
the robot at all times for safety's sake, have trouble
keeping up. The rover's wide, boxy body sits low to the
ground on fat mountain-bike tires; its shiny back of
solar panels feeds two racks of lithium-polymer
batteries below. Perched atop a long metal stalk of a
neck are three high-resolution color digital cameras,
used to look at terrain off in the distance; individual
images from these cameras can also be stitched together
to build panoramic views. Further down, two wide-angle
navigation cameras look a few meters in front of the
robot to detect obstacles.
Ungainly as the robot looks, Zoë in motion has a
certain gracefulness. Each wheel is driven
independently, while the front and rear axles, which
attach to a central "spine," pivot passively—going over
bumps, the robot's chassis appears to undulate. This
arrangement allows the wheels to remain on the ground at
all times and gives the machine a tight turning radius.
But controlling the drive isn't simple, Wettergreen
says. "It's not just a matter of giving the wheels the
right velocities. You have to be a little bit
predictive." Engineers at the Robotics Institute, where
the robot was designed and built, added a mechanical
linkage that averages the rolls of the front and rear
axles and the height of any obstacles the wheels are
going over and then distributes the load accordingly.
Zoë, whose name means "life" in Greek, is the
prototype of a vehicle that will likely rove Mars in the
not-too-distant future, hunting for evidence that some
kind of microbial life flourished in the planet's
warmer, watery past, as well as signs that some of it
might have held on to the present day. The most
important instrument in its suite is a fluorescence
imager that exploits the fact that certain substances
fluoresce when exposed to light at certain frequencies.
It will inspect rocks and dirt for the presence of
chlorophyll, lipids, carbohydrates, proteins, and
DNA—the chemical signatures of life. Chlorophyll glows
naturally when excited; the others do so only when
treated with special dyes.
In the lab, a fluorescence imager would excite the
sample using high-power lasers, each tuned to a
particular frequency. But the robot's unit has to be
compact and low-power, so it uses a xenon flashlamp,
which produces a 10-millisecond, 1000-watt burst of
full-spectrum light, explains Shmuel Weinstein, a
biologist at Carnegie Mellon who helped build the
imager. The light passes through a filter wheel, which
lets through just the frequencies that a sample might
emit when excited, and then into a fiber-optic bundle,
which directs the light to the sample below. The imager
also has a system for automatically applying the dyes,
water, and a mild acid (distilled vinegar, actually,
which breaks down cell walls and lets the dye penetrate)
to the sample. A charged-coupled-device (CCD) camera
takes pictures of the sample, first without the dye and
then with it; the robot then compares the images to see
where the sample is fluorescing.
Even after Zoë has gathered its pictures, the
scientists carefully reexamine the spot by hand,
collecting rock samples and, if necessary, running a
portable spectrometer over the ground. Later, they'll
compare the robot's data with their own. This process,
known as ground truthing, will tell them whether the
robot can be trusted. On Mars, researchers won't have
that chance, so it's better to know now.