A newly marketed anthrax
detector that originated in the U.S. space program
promises to halve the detection time of the system
currently used by the U.S. Postal Service. It was
devised by Universal Detection Technology Inc., in
Beverly Hills, Calif., building on work done by the Jet
Propulsion Laboratory (JPL) at the California Institute
of Technology, in Pasadena. If it proves its worth in
the field, the system may offer the Postal Service a
cheaper and more effective way of countering
bioterrorist attacks [see photo, "Terror"].
On 18 September 2001, exactly one week after the
9/11 attacks on the World Trade Center and Pentagon,
letters containing anthrax, all with Trenton, N.J.,
postmarks, were mailed to ABC News, CBS News, NBC News,
and the New York Post, all in New York City, and to the
National Enquirer and the Sun at American Media Inc., in
Boca Raton, Fla. Three weeks later, two more letters
containing the deadly substance, also with the Trenton
postmark, were discovered addressed to Democratic
Senators Tom Daschle of South Dakota and Patrick Leahy
of Vermont. In all, 22 people developed anthrax
infections; 17 became severely ill and 5 died. The
crimes are unsolved.
The anthrax spores in the deadly mailings contained
millions of dried bacterial cells, which remain in
suspended animation. If they are released into the air
and then come into contact with moist surfaces such as
nasal passages and lungs, they "wake up" and infect the
host. Inside the lungs, the spores germinate just like
plant seedlings and rapidly reproduce, causing fever,
suffocation, and death. If about 3000 anthrax spores are
breathed in within a half-hour, the dose is generally
fatal. Rarely, anthrax can also be contracted through
open cuts or sores on the skin, and this did occur in
some of the postal attacks.
In 2002 the Postal Service received US $762 million
from Congress to find and put into place an
early-warning anthrax detection system. Ever since,
research laboratories across the United States have been
engaged in trying to develop new ways to detect the
deadly spores. One of the first to succeed was a
Sunnyvale, Calif., bioresearch laboratory, Cepheid Inc.
It developed a genetic analysis system that could detect
anthrax—and more.
In 2004, the Postal Service tested five Cepheid
units, and it liked what it saw. The service installed
1700 units in 282 processing and distribution centers in
2005, at a cost of more than $250 million, or close to
$150 000 per unit. This expense does not include an
additional $100 million needed each year for operating
costs, such as replacing the chemical cartridges that
"sniff" for anthrax.
Named the GeneXpert, the Cepheid detector is simple
enough to be maintained by anyone with minimal training.
As mail whirs past the detector on sorting conveyors at
up to 160 kilometers per hour, the air above the sorter
is pumped into one of the chemical cartridges, which
sounds an alarm within 30 minutes if it detects anthrax.
Before, it would take a laboratory 24 hours or more for
an anthrax analysis. What's more, GeneXpert can detect
viruses that contain DNA, such as smallpox, or RNA, such
as Ebola. It can also detect the poison ricin if it is
in a crude extract containing DNA, says Kaye Chegwidden,
the company's director of biothreat operations.
But now, the California company Universal
Detection—which specializes in the manufacture of
airborne particulate and pollutant detectors—has built
a faster and cheaper device. "The time it takes for the
machine to detect the presence of anthrax spores once
the sample is collected is negligible—about 60
seconds—and the collection time is only 15 minutes,"
claims Amir Ettehadieh, the company's research director.
While the device is still undergoing final calibrations,
sales of individual units, for $45 000 each, have
already begun.
Universal Detection's BSM-2000 continuously samples
surrounding air for high concentrations of bacterial
spores—there are others, mostly benign, besides
anthrax. Normal room air contains naturally occurring
bacterial spores in low concentrations of 0.01 to 0.50
spores per liter. The detector triggers an alarm only on
registering a bacterial spore count of 50 or more per
liter, on the assumption that a bioterrorist attack will
release spores in much greater quantities than normally
found.
In the detector, a microwave beam delivered by a
fiber-optic system heats the outer shell of any
bacterial spore and causes it to explode and release a
particular chemical, dipicolinic acid (DPA), which is
characteristic of all bacteria, including anthrax. The
liberated DPA adheres to a tape strip within the device,
and if enough collects on the strip, ultraviolet light
causes a bright green luminescence to appear.
The GeneXpert system, in contrast, works on the
principle that when cells divide, enzymes called
polymerases are released that will prompt any contained
DNA or RNA located in the chromosomes to start making
copies. This is called a polymerase chain reaction.
So far, the GeneXpert detectors used by the Postal
Service have detected no anthrax and have delivered no
false positives. Given that solid performance, it's not
a foregone conclusion that the BSM-2000 will be deemed
superior and ultimately replace the GeneXpert,
especially considering that the service has already
invested heavily in the latter system. However, the
Postal Service has compelling budgetary reasons for
seriously considering alternatives in the longer term.
The service requested $779 million for emergency
preparedness for fiscal 2005 but obtained only $503
million from Congress. Unless there are additional
appropriations, the Postal Service will have to cover
biodefense expenditures out of its own revenues.
Besides being cheaper than the GeneXpert, the
BSM-2000 requires little maintenance and does not
require cartridge replacement, points out Ettehadieh.
The Postal Service says that as new technologies emerge,
it will evaluate them, working with the U.S. Department
of Homeland Security.
The project that led to the invention of the
BSM-2000 actually began in 2001, when NASA and JPL were
looking for a new, efficient way to detect any bacterial
spores clinging to spacecraft, to ensure that the
planets and moons in our solar system do not become
contaminated with germs from Earth. JPL created a device
called the RapidSSEA (rapid single spore enumeration
assay), and Universal Detection bought exclusive
development rights in 2002. Last year the company won
the Frost & Sullivan Technology Leadership Award for
its work in biological detection technology. It is
offering its new bacterial spore detector not only to
the Postal Service but also to federal, state, and local
government agencies.
Meanwhile, Universal Detection representatives have
met with the Postal Service, which has expressed
interest in learning more as results come in for the
BSM-2000 on tests for interferents and false-positive
rates.