Head north on the electromagnetic spectrum
from the 5.7-gigahertz Wi-Fi band, go past dozens of
dedicated satellite bands, and you’ll find 7 GHz of
unlicensed bandwidth just sitting there. There’s enough
bandwidth around 60GHz for a 2-gigabit-per-second
communications link—fast enough to wirelessly join a
high-definition DVD player and a high-definition TV, or
to beam a movie to an iPod in a flash.
What’s needed for such applications, however, are
radio transceiver chips cheap enough for consumer
electronics. That means silicon, not the gallium
arsenide used today at these frequencies.
Finally, researchers are coaxing silicon to operate
in this band. Last winter, IBM engineers unveiled the
first experimental 60-GHz transmitter and receiver
chips. This month, researchers at the University of
California, Los Angeles, are presenting three key
transceiver components built in a widely available and
inexpensive silicon process technology.
Millimeter-wave radios, those operating at 30 GHz and
above, have been available for many years. But because
of the high frequencies involved, they were built from
costly, difficult-to-integrate gallium arsenide.
Packaging the chips and connecting them to an antenna
without losing most of the signal added to their cost.
Only recently has a millimeter-wave silicon radio in
a cheap package even seemed possible. “When we first
talked about doing this in silicon, people laughed at
us,” says Brian Gaucher, who headed IBM’s
millimeter-wave radio effort at the Thomas J. Watson
Research Center, in Yorktown Heights, N.Y. Actually, IBM
does not use silicon alone. Rather, it uses a high-speed
alloy of silicon and germanium. IBM’s latest
silicon-germanium technology makes transistors that can
switch at a rate as fast as 200 GHz. Gaucher and his
colleagues built separate transmitter and receiver chips
with antennas incorporated right into the plastic
package, eliminating the need for signal- sapping
interconnects and economizing on packaging. The chips
communicated at 630megabits per second over a distance
of 10 meters.
UCLA electrical engineering professor Behzad Razavi
is taking a different approach from IBM’s. He’s making
key parts of his transmitters and receivers using
130-nanometer and 90-nm silicon CMOS manufacturing
technology—mature chip-making processes used today to
make microprocessors [see photo, “Wireless in Silicon”].
There could be two advantages to this. First, the
process technology is now so common and widespread that
the chips that result will no doubt be cheap. Second, as
the many millions of transistors on a microprocessor
attest, CMOS lets you integrate a lot of devices on the
same chip. “If I can put one antenna on a chip, I can
put on four,” says Razavi.
And CMOS transmitters at 60 GHz will need all the
antennas they can get. As individual transistors get
smaller, they will be less able to handle the power
required for RF transmission. So a likely solution will
be to put multiple transmitter circuits on a chip in
parallel.
“In general, for circuit design in deep submicron,
it’s easier to design several low-power transmitters
than one high-power one,” says Razavi. He plans to
integrate a number of transceivers on the same chip and
focus the resulting radio waves electronically into a
beam powerful enough to reach the 10 meters needed for a
personal area network.
Razavi concedes that his group is somewhat behind
IBM’s, but he feels that history is on his side. In the
past, radio chips, and 5-GHz Wi-Fi radios in particular,
started out in nonstandard transistor technologies, he
says. But, eventually, engineers found a way to get
ordinary silicon CMOS to do the same job, and for less
money.
In the past, the problem with switching to CMOS was
that the transistors lacked raw speed. At 60 GHz things
are far worse than they were at 5 GHz, and it’s not just
slow transistors. Instead, the problem is an inability
to predict how transistors and everything else on a chip
will work. CMOS circuit models today are accurate at
frequencies up to about 5 GHz; at 60 GHz everything
behaves differently. Razavi notes, for example, that any
interconnect on a 60-GHz chip longer than
20micrometers—that’s 20millionths of a meter—requires
complex calculations to be accurately depicted.
IBM expected the same problem, but it turned out that
its silicon-germanium circuit models worked surprisingly
well at 60 GHz, says Gaucher. If they work as well at
higher frequencies in the millimeter-wave regime, IBM
could go after other big applications. Gaucher notes
that Mercedes-Benz and other carmakers offer adaptive
cruise control based on a 77-GHz transceiver made of
gallium arsenide. Millimeter-wave imagers are also under
consideration for airport security, because they can see
through clothing.
However such specific applications may fare in the
real world, nobody is laughing at the idea of high-speed
silicon anymore. An IEEE standards group, 802.15.3c, is
hard at work defining specifications for such chips in a
2-Gb/s short-range, personal area network. More than 20
companies say they intend to participate in writing the
standard, including such heavy hitters as Fujitsu,
Freescale, Hewlett-Packard, Intel, Philips, and Samsung.
Proposals for the standard are to be submitted by
October, according to Reed E. Fisher, a senior scientist
at Tokyo-based Oki Electric Industry Co. and head of the
60-GHz standard working group. Then, in several rounds
of voting, the proposals will be pared down until only
one is left.