In just 15 years, the farmland of the
Pudong district of Shanghai
has disappeared under gleaming skyscrapers, monuments to,
among other things, the fastest-growing semiconductor industry
in the world. Within this charmed circle, the fastest-growing
start-up is Semiconductor Manufacturing International Corp.
(SMIC). In the five years since its founding, it has become
the leading chip maker in China, the next big chip-making
power in the world.
Ironically, China's ascendance in semiconductors is almost entirely
attributable to assistance from Taiwanese technologists. SMIC itself was
founded by a Chinese-American raised in Taiwan, and many of
its employees are from Taiwan. Hundreds of them, just weeks
off the airplane, are bedding down in the company's massive
employee community, complete with gym, supermarket, beauty
parlors, and a school for 1200 children.
SMIC is not the only foundry with roots in Taiwan that has set
up shop here. A report by a U.S. chip industry group, the
Semiconductor Industry Association, in San Jose, Calif., estimated
that in the second half of 2001 alone, more than 3000 engineers
left Taiwan to work in China's semiconductor industry. Far
more have evidently arrived since then. In Pudong, where three
of SMIC's foundries started operation two years ago, the Minnan
dialect of Taiwan can be heard in local bars and restaurants.
You'd think the outflow of expertise from Taiwan to the mainland
would make the Taiwanese very, very afraid. After all, they
invented the foundry model—the manufacture under contract
of chips by one company for another—and their government
has spent hugely on incentives to secure so much of the global
market.
The idea was for the foundries to grow, even at a loss, in order to
attain economies of scale that would deter others from entering
the business. And so far, the plan has worked. Taiwan controls
nearly two-thirds of the worldwide sales of the US $20 billion
foundry business, a business that is nearly a tenth of global
chip sales. What's more, the fraction of chips made in foundries
is projected to grow steadily for years to come.
Yet whatever their government may think, Taiwan's engineers aren't afraid
about ceding that lead to the mainland; they're here in China,
in the thousands.
"I seldom if ever talk to a non-Taiwanese person when I visit SMIC,"
says Michael G. Pecht, a mechanical engineering professor
at the University of Maryland, in College Park, who has written
extensively about Asian electronics industries. He adds, "I'm
not talking to senior management, and I'm not talking to the
factory workers—I'm talking to the people who know how
to make things work and understand the technology."
In fact, besides being home to Chinese foundries that are at least
partially staffed with Taiwanese workers, China also now boasts
shimmering new fab facilities built and operated by Taiwan-based
companies. Foremost among these is Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing
Co. (TSMC), in Hsinchu, the contract chip-making giant founded
in 1987 [see photos, "A Piece of the Action"].
It's tempting to look at the relationship between TSMC, the
largest foundry chip maker in the world, and the smaller
SMIC and see in it an ironic reversal of their respective
countries' big-brother-little-brother status. Viewed from
a global perspective, TSMC's worldwide sales of $7.6 billion
last year dwarfed the $1 billion in sales of SMIC. But
within China itself, SMIC is the bigger player, selling
half the chips made there. So with the foundries, little
brother is growing up fast, and big brother is acutely
aware of it [see photo, "In the Chips"].
It is just one of the many twists in this complicated, high-stakes,
fast-moving game. Even the basic parameters can be hard to
fathom: China provides incentives; the engineers come from
Taiwan to help staff local start-ups; Taiwanese companies
feel compelled to set up subsidiaries in China to compete
with the start-ups other Taiwanese are leading; then Taiwan's
government passes laws to slow things down, partly because
of acute diplomatic sensitivities but mainly out of concern
that mainland China is going to eat its lunch.