Fair’s ideas about
EML soon drew the attention of military
researchers in Washington, D.C. In December 1978, the
Defense Department invited him to brief a gathering of
top U.S. intelligence and military leaders. Renaming his
“Nutty Ideas” project the “National Advisory Panel on
Electromagnetic Propulsion,” he told the attendees of
EML’s enormous promise for artillery, aircraft
launchers, missile defense, fusion energy—and, of
course, space launch.
Fair’s pitch succeeded—sort of. Over the next two
years, he was able to fund EML research with, he says,
“peanuts—$100K or two.” He distributed the money among
the Francis Bitter National Magnet Laboratory (at MIT),
Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, Westinghouse
R&D Center, and his own Picatinny Arsenal.
More significantly, he organized (under the auspices
of the IEEE) the first of what would become biennial
symposia on electromagnetic launch. Over the years,
papers delivered at the symposia not only helped move
the field forward but also sparked interest in far-flung
parts of the globe. “This body of research is what the
Chinese and all new folks to the field now use as the
basic resource,” says Fair.
At least one project Fair funded had a checkered past.
In the early 1970s, Princeton University physics
professor Gerard K. O’Neill had gotten enthusiastic
about EML. NASA’s Apollo missions were still in full
swing, and O’Neill dreamed of building entire cities in
orbit. In the August 1974 issue of Physics Today, he
described floating colonies built of cylinders 6 km wide
and 26 km long, and inside of them, picturesque towns
with meadows, lakes, sunshine, and even clouds.
Rather than rocketing construction materials into
space, he proposed mining lunar rock and then shipping
it to an orbiting manufacturing plant. The rock would be
moved around by a solar-powered EM launcher—much
cheaper than shipping rocket fuel to the moon, he
reasoned. Best of all, O’Neill concluded, rather
dubiously, these colonies could be created “with
existing technology.”
Someone in NASA apparently agreed, because in 1976 the
space agency awarded a $50 000 contract to O’Neill and
MIT professor Henry Kolm, part of which they used to
build a coilgun. Called the Mass Driver I, the
8-meter-long device had its public debut at Princeton,
in the lobby of Chadwin Hall, where a conference on
space colonies was taking place. A student fished a
copper-coil-wrapped bucket—the gun’s projectile—out of
a tub of liquid nitrogen, slid it into the barrel, and
bang! The crowd erupted in applause as the bucket
appeared instantaneously, or so it seemed, at the far
end of the gun, colliding with a thud into a padded
barrier that kept it from flying the length of the
lobby. Kolm estimated the bucket reached a peak speed of
63 m/s. Though the performance was many orders of
magnitude below the theoretical upper limit for EML, the
experiment was declared a success.
To build Mass Driver II would require more funding,
but before NASA could approve it, Wisconsin senator
William Proxmire got wind of O’Neill’s space colonies
idea. Famed for his “Golden Fleece” awards for
government spending he deemed wasteful, Proxmire went on
television to proclaim “not another penny for this nutty
fantasy.” NASA quickly pulled the plug on all its space
colonies projects, including the Mass Driver.
Fair, though, believed the project was worth
continuing, and in 1979 he contacted O’Neill and Kolm
and said he’d fund their work.
Then Fair came across
Richard Marshall. Shortly after his
record-setting railgun test in Australia, Marshall, too,
had lost his funding. He left the university, moved to
the United States, and got a job with Westinghouse in
Pittsburgh, where Fair found him in 1979.
Fair, Marshall, Kolm, and their associates now had to
confront the enormous technical problems that
electromagnetic guns pose. First and foremost is the
power supply. Your garden-variety diesel generator won’t
work. All railguns and coilguns require a power source
that can generate, store, and then emit an enormous
burst of current—anywhere from 500 000 to many millions
of amperes in a few milliseconds. Marshall had used a
homopolar generator, so named because its magnetic field
has the same polarity at every point. Just like any
generator, it converts rotational mechanical energy into
electrical energy. But instead of continuously
converting the kinetic energy into electrical energy,
the homopolar generator’s rotors store the energy up and
then release it in a several-millisecond pulse. Another
early railgun experiment called for hooking together
thousands of lead-acid car batteries to supply the
requisite juice.
Dumping that much current so quickly raises other
problems. To begin with, you need a very-large-diameter
cable to deliver so much current—anything smaller would
melt. The switch, too, has to be specially designed to
prevent a massive arc that would otherwise destroy the
switch the instant it was thrown. And in the case of a
coilgun, where you’re switching the coils on and off in
rapid succession, it’s easy to mistime the switching,
which in turn can make the projectile wobble. Too much
wobble and it won’t leave the barrel at anything close
to the target velocity and may also collide with and
damage the barrel.
Needless to say, railguns also have a tendency to
self-destruct. The high-velocity projectile and armature
gouge the rails, and the magnetic fields put a
tremendous strain on the rails as they try to force
themselves apart. Researchers have considered using
superconducting magnets to generate the strong fields
needed, but existing superconductors are too brittle and
can’t withstand large, rapid changes in their magnetic fields.
Even the projectiles are a subject of intense inquiry.
They leave the barrel at such high velocity that when
they hit the air, they tend to flatten, burn up, or
shatter. That’s why Marshall and others used small,
nonconducting pieces of plastic. But for real-world
uses, you’d like some way of guiding the projectile to
its final destination, tens or hundreds of kilometers
away. To send a satellite into space, for instance,
you’d equip the payload with some sort of second-stage
rocket to insert it into the proper orbit once the
payload left the atmosphere. But the conventional
electronics of the 1970s couldn’t survive the massive
acceleration that an electromagnetic gun produces.