Sci-Tech: The Movie Continued
By Stephen Cass
First Published July 2006
As it happens, this panel provides a good example of
my one caveat regarding the site: everything in the
fields of science, engineering, and technology tends
to get lumped under the single umbrella term “science.”
For example, despite Apollo 13's being centered on a
purely engineering problem—an explosion aboard a
spacecraft—and the fact that most of the characters
portrayed in the movie are engineers, the discussion
about the film is couched in terms of the issues
involved with presenting “science” and “science
problems” to a movie audience. It may sound like
semantics, but in an otherwise terrific effort to
improve the public's understanding of science and
technology, this lack of distinction can, ironically,
present a distorted image of science—and do a
disservice to engineers in the bargain.
Photo: Museum of the Moving Image
|
THE END OF THE WORLD?: Teen angst is reflected by the uncertain fate
of Skylab.
|
This nit aside, the Sloan Foundation and the Museum of
the Moving Image are to be commended, not just for
opening the door to substantive dialogue between the
worlds of science, technology, and film, but also for
making the fruits of that dialogue so accessible.
Fifteen short films are available on the site to watch
for free, ranging in length from 7 to 29 minutes. My
favorites are The
Monster and the Peanut, about a man who
believes he can find the reason for his daughter's
death if only he can figure out how to model traffic
flow [see photo, “A Driven Man”], and Skylab, in which
a boy spends a summer worrying that the sky will
literally fall on his head [see photo, “The End of The
World?”]. Another notable film is Gray Matter, an
unflinching look at a coroner's investigation into a
child's death. Be warned, though: the film includes a
grisly and graphic scene of an autopsy that makes this
depiction of a forensic investigator's work very
different from television shows like “C.S.I.” and its
spin-offs. (That said, “C.S.I.” does generally work hard
to get the science right; see “Inside Hollywood,”
Spectrum, December 2005.)
The only movie I really didn't like was Paprika, an
animated tale that aims to depict Nobel Prize–winner
Albert Szent-Györgyi's identification of Vitamin C as
ascorbic acid. In the film, the secret of Vitamin C is
told to Szent-Györgyi by a homunculus that, one day,
just happens to magically emerge from a red pepper.
Isn't the idea of revealed wisdom delivered by
supernatural entities, though, inherently antithetical
to science?
Still, the obvious creativity of all the featured
filmmakers suggests that there will be something for
nearly every taste on the site. I urge even the most
cold-bloodedly analytical engineer to check out these
artistic offerings—who knows, they may even give you a
new perspective on your work. Just don't start talking
to the red pepper people.
To Probe Further
For more about the interface between science,
technology, and film, check out David Kushner's Web-only
column, “The Science of Hollywood,” at
http://www.spectrum.ieee.org.