When Albert Belle was arrested in February for
stalking his former girlfriend, it wasn’t the
technology he used that got him into the papers—it was
his fame as a retired major league baseball player [see
photo, “Ball’s
Belle”]. But if convicted, the five-time
All-Star outfielder will enter a growing rogues’ gallery
of those who have used Global Positioning System (GPS)
devices to track and torment former loved ones.
According to the Scottsdale, Ariz., police report on
Belle, in late January an object fell off the
Mercedes-Benz sedan of his ex-girlfriend after she hit a
bump. When she stopped to see what it was, she found a
small black box with two magnets attached and a
phonelike device inside. She told police that Belle had
frequently shown up at unusual times and in odd places,
and she believed he was following her. After she
recorded phone conversations in which Belle seemed to be
threatening her, he was arrested and indicted on a
felony charge of stalking using a GPS device.
The case, just one of many, is a dramatic illustration
of how an otherwise benign technology with many
wonderful applications can turn into a real threat in
the wrong hands.
GPS, originally developed by the U.S. Department of
Defense, has been widely adapted for civilian uses in
the last 10 years. One of the best-known applications is
General Motors Corp.’s OnStar, which directs drivers to
their destinations. Aftermarket versions that offer only
tracking sell for less than US $1000 and can be wired
directly into a car’s 12-volt electrical system.
The mobile GPS tracking equipment used in systems like
OnStar rely on a matchbook-size sensor that receives
signals from satellites. Processing logic triangulates
the signals to locate the device to a resolution of
roughly 2 meters. Early versions of such aftermarket
devices had to be removed from the vehicle and connected
to a computer to download their data, but newer models
include a cellular transmitter that uploads the location
data to a server. Users can track the vehicle via
constantly updated Web pages or have text messages with
the location data sent to mobile phones—a big temptation
for those inclined to stalk estranged lovers, given the
patchiness of existing laws.
The rules governing malicious uses of the technology
vary widely from state to state in the United States.
Many states have general laws against stalking or
harassment, but far fewer specifically address GPS
tracking, mobile phones, Internet spyware, and other
recent developments in consumer technology.
The first recorded prosecution for GPS stalking was in
Boulder, Colo., in October 2000. Robert Sullivan was
convicted of harassment for having his teenaged sons
install a TravelEyes Tracking Unit, sold by Bluewater
Security, in Ann Arbor, Mich., in his estranged wife’s
Oldsmobile. He was sentenced to three years in jail
after the court ruled that the phrase “under
surveillance” in that state’s stalking law included
electronic monitoring. Though his jail time was
subsequently reduced, he was later rearrested and jailed
for multiple parole violations.
In 2003, Paul Seidler of Kenosha, Wis., was sentenced
to nine months after he was convicted of felony stalking
of his ex‑girlfriend. His innovation was to use a newly
available real-time tracking service that depended on a
GPS device he hid in her car that sent mobile text
messages informing him where she was traveling so that
he could pull up alongside her several times a day.
Harassment and stalking are no laughing matter.
Domestic violence is responsible for 2 million injuries
and nearly 1300 deaths among U.S. women age 18 and
older, according to a division of the U.S. Centers for
Disease Control and Prevention. (No solid data on the
number of stalking cases are available, says Cindy
Southworth, technology director of the National Network
to End Domestic Violence, in Washington, D.C., because
no standard reporting system exists among
law-enforcement agencies.)
For anyone suspecting that she is a victim of GPS
stalking, advice is surprisingly low-tech: first, trust
your instincts, says Southworth; if someone repeatedly
knows your travel patterns, be suspicious. Second, if
you fear your vehicle is being tracked, talk to local
law enforcement officers or a service station manager.
Either the police or a mechanic can search your
vehicle—although if any suspicious device is found, a
mechanic must leave it undisturbed so it can be
inspected as police evidence.
Southworth worries that GPS stalking will become more
common as sensors and transmitters grow ever smaller and
consume less power. What’s more, with all new U.S.
mobile phones on track to provide GPS positioning data
to the emergency 911 system, any phone can be tracked if
the carrier chooses to offer such a service. No national
law requires that a cellphone customer be notified that
location data is being tracked, nor is the customer’s
consent needed to record such data.
Though phone companies almost certainly would not
intentionally provide tracking data to third parties
without the customer’s permission, Southworth says she
has seen cases in which a person managed to obtain
tracking data for an estranged spouse. To avoid becoming
a victim, people are advised to check with their
cellphone service providers to find out if tracking is
on and where tracking data are being sent, and to change
all passwords giving access to their accounts.
If you consider yourself to be at risk, remember that
stalking behavior is often a deep and intractable
obsession. Baseball player Belle was rearrested on
17 May for continuing to harass the same woman. He had
reportedly made dozens of hang-up calls and harassing
comments, despite being under court order to refrain
from any contact with her. He will now remain in jail
until his case is heard.
Belle is learning the hard way that what goes around
comes around: the electronic monitoring device he had to
wear around his ankle before his second arrest also used
GPS data to calculate the position of its wearer.