Exactly how to make a
business out of a technological advance
wasn't immediately clear to the Ntera founders. Seeing
themselves as researchers more than businessmen, the
team initially envisioned Ntera as a holding pen for
intellectual property, licensing their breakthroughs to
others who would turn them into products.
But after a few years the executives realized that
they would have to make products themselves, at least
initially—hence the fabrication line in Taiwan. After
the technology catches on, Ntera plans to get out of the
manufacturing business. What it wants to do is control
production of the inklike slurries of nanoparticles and
electrochromic molecule formulas, which it will sell to
licensees, much in the way Coca-Cola sells its secret
syrup to bottlers. The company also expects to collect
royalties from products made with its inventions.
Meanwhile, Ntera plans to continue developing and
extending its basic technology, in hopes of moving
beyond the low-information display market into sexier
stuff. Ntera envisions three such product extensions
already—full-color, active-matrix displays, like those
ubiquitous in laptop computers; flexible plastic
displays for use in clothing and packaging; and
transparent displays, for which a first application
might be an electronic iris for cellphone cameras.
Right now, NCD displays are monochromatic, though
they can come in different colors, depending on the
specific oxide used. But Ntera executives see no reason
why they can't get a piece of the market for full-color
active-matrix displays in mobile devices like phones and
PDAs. So far, they've identified electrochromic
molecules that reflect blue and green—two of the three
primary colors needed to make all of the colors visible
to the human eye. The third color, red, has been more
elusive, but, says CTO Corr, a solution for red appears
to be close.
Nor has Ntera entirely given up on the
still-nascent—but potentially huge—market for roll-up
newspapers and other flexible displays.
"One of the big advantages of our technology is that
it can be migrated onto plastic," Corr says. Plastic can
replace the glass plates of an NCD because the
technology does not require a precise and stable
distance between the two plates, as is the case with an
LCD. Warping or bending the display may push the
electrolyte around a little but has little or no effect
on the color-changing molecules that create the image.
Yet another possibility is transparent displays, which
Ntera has already begun experimenting with. Making an
NCD transparent simply means leaving out one of the
layers of titanium dioxide particles.
In any of its markets, the NCD will face off against
a variety of contenders. LCDs, of course, have the
benefit of industry inertia. In addition, several
companies have their own electrochromic displays in the
works. Siemens AG, in Munich, Germany, recently
demonstrated a small printable display, which it hopes
to have on the market in 2007. Printable, flexible
electrochromic displays are also under development at
Acreo AB, in Kista, Sweden, and Aveso Inc., in Fridley,
Minn. Given the number of options available, "any
display technology is in for quite a challenging time,"
says Adrian Geisow, manager of displays research at HP
Labs Bristol, in England.
But Ntera seems to stack up well against many of its
apparent opponents developing new flat-panel
technologies. Organic electroluminescent display (OELD)
technology, which, like NCD, is potentially flexible,
requires a large capital investment—tens of millions of
dollars at least—and costs, Nick How estimates, about
$3 per square inch to make. A product of equivalent size
containing Ntera's technology would cost a fraction of
this—as little as one-tenth, by some estimates.
"Perhaps somebody we don't know about has a cracking
good idea that is so good and easy to make that in two
years they'll have a jump on us," Corr says. "But I sure
don't see anybody like that out there."
Meanwhile, as this article was going to press, the
first commercial NCD products were rolling off the
assembly line. You'll see them soon on store shelves.
And Corr and Fitzmaurice will be proud papas. "To this
day, eight years after we made the first one, I do
believe it really is a thing of beauty," Corr said. "And
it is just cool to say that this is something I helped
bring to life."
With additional
reporting by Steven Cherry.
NanoChromics Display
GOAL: Create
an electronic display for the consumer market as easy to
read as paper.
WHY IT'S A
WINNER: It looks like ink on paper, and it
has a high contrast ratio and a wide viewing angle. It's
visible everywhere, even in bright sunlight. It consumes
little power and is cheap to manufacture.
ORGANIZATION:
Ntera Ltd.
CENTER OF
ACTIVITY: Dublin, Ireland.
NUMBER OF PEOPLE ON THE
PROJECT: 35 and growing.
BUDGET:
Approximately US $35 million to date.