Bumping along
in Ingram's old pickup truck, we pull into Hoeganaes
Corp.'s steel plant near Gallatin, Tenn., outside
Nashville. Overhead, power lines are coming in from a
988-megawatt coal-fired power plant 8 kilometers away.
Big graphite cylinders wait in boxes—replacement
electrodes for the plant's arc furnace, in which scrap
steel is melted down to make powder, primarily for the
auto parts manufacturers that are legion in this part of
the country. There's metal scrap mixed in with the
gravel on the plant's driveway, which doesn't make the
ride any smoother in Ingram's modest truck.
The SuperVAR machine itself, at first glance, isn't
much to look at: it's just a shipping container sitting
on a flatbed truck. In the substation just behind it, I
hear birds chirping—"faux birds," that is. The sounds
are recorded songs of distressed birds played to scare
away real birds that might fly into the station and
short out circuits, explains Ingram, a lanky,
thin-lipped Alabamian with a dry sense of humor.
PHOTO: American Superconductor Corp.
|
Exciting the grid: David Madura, chief engineer (left) and Hank
Valcour, principal engineer, check out SuperVAR,
which is housed for testing in a container on a
flatbed truck.
|
We are joined at the machine by Charles ("Chuck")
Stankiewicz, vice president and general manager of
American Superconductor's power electronics unit in
Middleton, Wis., which analyzes transmission grids and
sells SuperVAR machines. Also on hand is David Madura,
product manager and chief engineer for the SuperVAR
machine at American Superconductor, as well as other
representatives of the company and TVA. Stankiewicz has
flown in from Wisconsin and Madura from Massachusetts,
and Ingram himself has just driven 3 hours from
Chattanooga, to show off and explain what they all
obviously think is a very hot item [see photo, "Exciting
the Grid"].
This steel plant is an ideal place to test the
SuperVAR, because its huge arc furnaces put enormous and
fast-varying inductive loads on the grid, consuming
large quantities of reactive power erratically. The arc
can vary between extinction, at zero current, to the
short-circuit condition, caused by scrap contacting the
electrode, says Ingram. Physical movement of both the
solid charge pieces and the melt cause variations in the
arc length—fluctuations that can occur many times a
second. Superimposed on these effects are variations
caused by mechanical vibration of the electrode and its
supporting structure.
Conceptually, the SuperVAR machine is simple enough.
The rotor is a large thermos bottle, about 2 to 3 meters
long, containing liquid neon at 27 degrees above
absolute zero. In principle, a SuperVAR could be built
to run on liquid nitrogen at 77 degrees above absolute
zero, but current densities would be lower and the
number of wire windings greater. The neon comes from a
cryocooler in which the primary loop runs on gaseous
helium. Inside the thermos are the rotor coils, made
from American Superconductor's first-generation
superconducting wires.
SuperVAR can work two ways. It can provide
compensating reactive power continuously to the grid as
needed. A sensor provides readings of how much current
is lagging voltage, and the control unit tells the
exciter to inject the needed compensating reactive
capacitance. Or the voltage can be set at a suitable
level in the rotor, so that it spontaneously adds the
compensating reactive power when the grid voltage starts
to drop.
The SuperVAR setup at the mill is designed, says
Ingram, to provide accelerated test conditions. Running
on a 13.8-kilovolt circuit that feeds Hoeganaes's
50-megavoltampere arc furnace, the SuperVAR machine has
been in operation for 3000 hours. It has gone through
more than 2300 melt cycles, in which 140 million
kilograms of steel have been melted. That's the
equivalent, says Ingram with a note of irony, of melting
100 000 Porsche Boxsters.
Hoeganaes, the owner of the mill where SuperVAR is
being put through its paces, bills itself as one of the
world's largest makers of ferrous metal powders. As we
stand next to the SuperVAR machine, a scrap bucket
carrier rolls into the mill, destined for the arc
furnace. It takes 60 tons of scrap to make a standard
load, and a melt takes place—the big electrodes dipping
down into the furnace—about once an hour.
Stepping into a building behind the trailer, where
monitoring devices and controls are located, we wait for
the next melt. After a while, there's a big rumble, and
voltage levels dive drastically—by as much as 20
percent—on the meters we're looking at. We step back to
the trailer to listen for the SuperVAR to kick in, but
the machine is almost noiseless. Nevertheless, the whole
structure is vibrating from the enormous, instantaneous
torquing of the SuperVAR in response to the melt
operation going on in the adjacent building. It's a
punishing environment, and it's exactly what SuperVAR's
designers had in mind for this initial test.
Besides running almost
flawlessly so far, the SuperVAR has
several inherent advantages over the standard
synchronous condensers that do not rely on
superconductors. Because there is no heating in its
rotor, there are virtually no thermal stresses and no
losses in its field coils. Also, thanks to the large air
gap between the stator and rotor coils—a feature that
is possible because the current density in the
superconducting coils is so high—the machine is able to
inject on demand lots of current and, hence, lots of
reactive power.
Exploiting the large gap between rotor and stator,
SuperVAR's designers were able to surround the rotor
coils with an aluminum conductive tube or shield. It's
this feature that enables the machine to react so
vigorously to drops in reactive power on the grid.
Basically, when there is a transient on the circuit
running through the stator, currents in the shield
spontaneously oppose what's happening in the grid, says
Bruce Gamble, providing a shorthand explanation. Gamble
is American Superconductor's director of engineering for
supermachines.
So SuperVAR is expected to be a cost-effective source
of dynamic reactive power. What's more, its footprint is
much smaller than those of equally rated conventional
machines—a very important factor, especially in urban
grids where substation space is scarce. In many places,
because of the somewhat haphazard way the grid has been
reorganized in the era of restructuring and
deregulation, reactive power is not always provided
efficiently.
To provide a sense of the potential market,
Stankiewicz and Ingram note that TVA, with generating
capacity of about 30 gigawatts, has 259 capacitor banks
with a total rating of 9.4 gigavoltamperes-reactive
(GVAR). Scaling to the whole United States, which has
more than 700 GW of generators, there might be as much
as 250 GVAR of transmission capacitors—all candidates
for replacement by superconducting synchronous
condensers. Of course, not every situation will be
suitable for a SuperVAR-type device, but even a modest
slice of the global transmission market would be a big
market indeed.
If the market develops as SuperVAR's boosters expect,
it's unlikely that American Superconductor will own it
all forever. But the company was well positioned to
devise the first prototype. The innovation was a happy
conjunction, really, of several corporate developments.
One was its commercialization of first-generation
superconductor wire manufacturing technology, which the
company accomplished by working closely with researchers
at Oak Ridge National Laboratory, near Knoxville, Tenn.
Two years ago, American Superconductor opened a
production line for its first-generation wire in Devens,
Mass., where it is turning out about 400 km of it each
year.
Another development was American Superconductor's
acquisition of a leading firm in Wisconsin that makes
the big semiconductor devices used in power electronics.
That division now makes power electronic converters and
devices based on insulated gate bipolar transistors
(IGBTs) that are used not only in SuperVAR and other
reactive power products but in fuel cellÂpowered buses
to be tested in Winnipeg, Man., Canada, and in wind
farms being built by Denmark's Vestas Wind Systems AS,
the world's top windmill manufacturer.
Finally, American Superconductor has had considerable
experience and success with rotating superconducting
machinery in the context of the U.S. Navy's motor
demonstration program. The company has so far built and
delivered a 5-MW superconducting motor for the Navy and
is presently making a 36.5-MW propulsion motor. These
motors have some important similarities with the
SuperVAR machine. The Navy's imprimatur, notes Ingram,
was a critical factor in TVA's decision to proceed with
American Superconductor on SuperVAR.