As an example, he cited the city traffic department's
network of cameras to monitor traffic flow around the
city. The mesh network could be used to bring images
from the cameras back to the traffic management center.
It could also help municipal work crews, equipped with
mesh-enabled laptops out in the field, to download
instructions and schematics from city databases.
Before long, interest began to spread to other city
departments. For emergency services, for instance,
Cheetah recently staged a demonstration of how
responders could use the network to communicate during
an emergency that included videoconferencing in the
field. Cervantes has lent the fire department some mesh
cards so it can start testing the pilot network.
The mesh network also offers an opportunity for Las
Vegas to solve its interoperability problem. What
visitors think of as a single glitzy metropolis is
actually a patchwork of municipalities and areas that
fall under the control of the surrounding county. Even
the Las Vegas Strip, the city's signature avenue of
outlandish hotels and casinos, is nearly all part of an
unincorporated township called Paradise.
As a result, when major problems arise, it's
difficult to coordinate the different agencies involved,
such as the fire and police departments. "We've got four
or five different cities, and it seems that each city
has a different communications system," says Cervantes.
"The mesh network could be a way to bridge that
interoperability gap" if each city joined the mesh
network.
Cervantes and Cheetah worked out a deal to start
building a proof-of-concept network last summer. The Las
Vegas traffic department agreed to provide most of the
manpower and the lampposts needed to deploy the network
hardware and pay Cheetah $25 000 to defray its costs.
Cheetah provided all the equipment but retains ownership
of it, pending the city's decision on installing a
full-scale network.
Cheetah refuses to disclose the per-unit cost of the
equipment but said the Las Vegas pilot network cost
about $175 000—or roughly $80 000 per 2.6 km2. Of that,
$30 000 pays for things like the servers Cheetah uses to
manage the network and the cost of connecting it to the
Internet, but the bulk, $50 000, is the cost of the mesh
hardware itself.
Cheetah's hardware comes from Maitland, Fla.-based
MeshNetworks Inc. [see "10 Tech Companies for the Next
10 Years," IEEE Spectrum, November 2003]. As this
article went to press, communications technology giant
Motorola Inc. announced it had signed an agreement to
acquire MeshNetworks, with the stated intention of
introducing mesh technology across all of Motorola's
business units, from home entertainment to cellphones.
While Motorola has its own sales force, licensed
resellers such as Cheetah have been grandfathered into
the agreement, says Rick Rotondo, MeshNetwork's vice
president of marketing. He expects that many of
MeshNetwork's current resellers will be used on a
contract basis by Motorola to deploy and operate future
mesh systems, because of their experience and wealth of
regional contacts.
Cheetah also sells two other types of mesh networks
based on hardware from Tropos Networks Inc., in
Sunnyvale, Calif., and BelAir Networks Inc, in Kanata,
Ont., Canada. The Tropos and BelAir mesh systems are
built on top of the IEEE 802.11 Wi-Fi protocol, while
MeshNetworks uses a proprietary technology originally
developed for military applications.
Compared with the Wi-Fi-based mesh systems, the
military-derived technology offers improved resistance
to radio interference, better security, built-in
geolocation, and the ability to offer different levels
of service to different types of users. It also allows
users to move about seamlessly within the entire
coverage area, instead of having to re-establish a
connection as they move from one Wi-Fi hotspot to
another.
Within the Las Vegas MeshNetworks system, the average
transmission speed ranges from 500 kilobits per second
to 1.5 Mb/s, with bursts of up to 6 Mb/s possible. The
backbone of the network is made up of 33 or so
shoe-box-size gray boxes attached to traffic-light poles
high above the streets, known as wireless routers [see
photo, "Betting on the
House"]. During the pilot deployment, city
workers with a bucket truck managed in one 8-hour shift
to put up 18 routers, says Cheetah's Gonzalez. Routers
are simply bolted to lampposts and plugged into the
photocell power adapter that sits atop most
streetlights. The routers are then automatically
assimilated into the mesh network. The most
time-consuming element of installing or removing one is
the time required to put traffic cones around the work
area.