It sounds too good to be true: high-quality
flat lenses that focus light and can be made in sheets
and cut to size. That's the promise of a new class of
materials with a negative refractive index that bend
light in the opposite direction from conventional
materials [see diagram].
There's a problem, however. These materials are hard
to make. The first ones were made in 1999, and the only
ones created to date operate in the microwave region and
consist of a complex assembly of copper rings and wires
that must be painstakingly assembled by hand into a
periodic structure [see "Left-Handed Material Reacts to
3-D Light," IEEE Spectrum, October 2002]. Such materials
are not mass-producible using known techniques.
That could be about to change. According to Tom
Mackay, a mathematician at the University of Edinburgh,
and Akhlesh Lakhtakia, a mechanical engineer at
Pennsylvania State University, in University Park,
another way to make them is to take a handful of one
material and mix it with another. Their breakthrough is
the discovery that blended materials can have properties
that were not present in the originals.
The possibility of negative refraction was first
raised in the late 1960s by the Russian physicist Victor
Veselago of the General Physics Institute of the Russian
Academy of Sciences in Moscow. Veselago based his ideas
on the discovery by James Clerk Maxwell that light's
behavior in a material could be described in terms of
two constants: for the magnetic field, the material's
permeability, and for the electric field, its
permittivity.
The permittivity and permeability of all natural
materials have positive values. Veselago asked what
would happen if he switched the sign of these constants
from positive to negative, and found that the material
would bend light in the opposite direction it normally
is refracted.
Taking Veselago's thought experiments a step further,
Mackay and Lakhtakia asked whether ordinary materials
could ever combine in a way that produces negative
permittivity and permeability. To their surprise, the
equations showed that this is possible using easily
available materials. "One material needs to be metallic
in character while the other must be magnetic," says
Mackay. "It was really a very unexpected result."
There are a couple of other conditions. The materials
must be formed as spheres that are about the same size
as the wavelength of light they are designed to bend.
And the materials must be mixed in certain proportions.
Mackay says that the technique should make it possible
to bend visible light the wrong way for the first time.
"Nanoparticles of the size needed to manipulate
visible light are now common," he says. "There is
nothing to prevent this from working in the optical
regime." Until now, however, the technique has worked
only with microwave.