PHOTO: Bob O'Conner
|
Keeping aging systems on their feet is a daunting and
resource-intensive task. The U.S. Air Force, for
example, continually wages an internal battle to keep
its weapons systems in fighting form. One enormous and
often overlooked factor contributing to the early demise
of military technologies is the problem of unavailable
parts. , significant components of the
aircraft's defensive management system, just one small
part of its electronics, were obsolete. Repairing the
system entailed either redesigning a few circuit boards
and replacing other obsolete integrated circuits for US
$21 million, as the B-2 program officers chose to do, or
spending $54 million to have the original contractor
replace the whole system. The electronics, in essence,
were fine—they just couldn't easily be fixed if even
the slightest thing went wrong.
Although mundane in its simplicity, the inevitable
depletion of crucial components as systems age has
sweeping, potentially life-threatening consequences. At
the very least, the quest for an obsolete part can
escalate into an unexpected, budget-busting expense.
Electronics obsolescence—also known as DMSMS, for
diminishing manufacturing sources and material
shortages—is a huge problem for designers who build
systems that must last longer than the next cycle of
technology. For instance, by the time the U.S. Navy
began installing a new sonar system in surface ships in
2002, more than 70 percent of the system's electronic
parts were no longer being made. And it's not just the
military: commercial airplanes, communications systems,
and amusement-park rides must all be designed around
this problem, or the failure of one obsolete electronic
part can easily balloon into a much larger system
failure.
The crux is that semiconductor manufacturers mainly
answer the needs of the consumer electronics industry,
whose products are rarely supported for more than four
years. Dell lists notebook computer models in its
catalog for about 18 months. This dynamic hurts
designers with long lead times on products with even
longer field lives, introducing materials, components,
and processes that are incompatible with older ones.
The defining characteristic of an obsolete system is
that its design must be changed or updated merely to
keep the system in use. Qinetiq Technology Extension
Corp., in Norco, Calif., a company that provides
obsolescence-related resources, estimates that
approximately 3 percent of the global pool of electronic
components becomes obsolete each month. PCNAlert, a
commercial service that disseminates notices from
manufacturers that are about to discontinue or alter a
product, reports receiving about 50 discontinuance
alerts a day. In my capacity as an associate professor
of mechanical engineering at the University of Maryland,
College Park, and a member of the university's Center
for Advanced Life Cycle Engineering, I have been
developing tools to forecast and resolve obsolescence
problems. To deal with that growing pile of unavailable
supplies, engineers in charge of long-lasting systems
must basically predict the future—they must learn to
plan well in advance, and more carefully than ever
before, for the day their equipment will start to fail.
Call it the dark side of moore’s law: poor
planning causes companies to spend progressively more
to deal with aging systems
The systems hit hardest by obsolescence are the ones
that must perform nearly flawlessly. Technologies for
mass transit, medicine, the military, air-traffic
control, and power-grid management, to name a few,
require long design and testing cycles, so they cannot
go into operation soon after they are conceived. Because
they are so costly, they can return the investment only
if they are allowed to operate for a long time, often 20
years or more. Indeed, by 2020, the U.S. Air Force
projects that the average age of its aircraft will
exceed 30 years—although some of the electronics will
no doubt have been replaced by then.
Some of the best examples of obsolescence come from
the U.S. military, because it has been managing
long-cycle technology programs longer than just about
any other organization in the world. But there are also
commercial aircraft that fall into the same, almost
incredible age range of 40 to 90 years. The Boeing 737
was introduced in 1965 and the 747 in 1969; neither is
expected to retire anytime soon.
When those systems were first built, the problem of
obsolete electronics was only vaguely addressed, if at
all, because the military still ruled the electronics
market, and the integrated circuits they needed remained
available for much longer than they do now. In the
1960s, the expected market availability for chips was
between 20 and 25 years; now it's between two and five.
Call it the dark side of Moore's Law, which states that
the number of transistors on a chip doubles every 18 to
20 months: poor planning for parts obsolescence causes
companies and militaries to spend progressively more to
deal with the effects of aging systems—which leaves
even less money for new investment, in effect creating a
downward spiral of maintenance costs and delayed
upgrades.