To
Understand This Risk Aversion, you've got to know
more about how VC firms are organized. First, a venture capitalist
isn't a guy with a giant bag of money over his shoulder, dollar
bills and gold coins spilling out. Behind the cartoon character
is not one but several different people with different roles.
The people with big money to invest—sometimes billions of
dollars—don't know much about technology and innovation.
Instead, they turn their money over to people who do (or so
they hope).
Basically,
venture capitalists combine these investments into a sort
of mutual fund of start-ups. As the start-up passes through
various well-defined stages of development, other investors
are brought in to fund the company, thereby lessening the
risk, and also the potential reward, as the fund matures.
It turns out that most investors won't fund an operation before
it has a measurable cash flow, so it takes a special investor
to put money into a company at its earliest stages of existence.
VCs talk
about funding rounds in alphabetical order. Series A investments
are backing something that's little more than a technology
and a team. The business will need to acquire other skills,
such as sales, marketing, customer service, and operations
management, to be successful. Series B investments are the
order of the day when a company has a working prototype product
and initial orders, as well as a more complete management
team with diverse business skills. Series C investments are
made when a company has more than one customer, working products,
marketing and sales channels in place, and a growing pipeline
of sales prospects. Pricing and gross profit margins on those
sales are no longer mysteries, and working capital is needed
mainly for components and support.
Series
A funding is usually in relatively small amounts—there are
often fewer than 10 people employed by the company, and the
biggest expense is their salaries. Series B is typically much
larger; not only is more money needed, but it's easier to
get, because risk has decreased. By the time of series C,
the dollar figures have increased again, to meet the heavy
expenses of raw materials, components, and inventory; moreover,
risk has decreased even further. The number of potential investors
increases with each funding round, and each new investor at
each round tends to commit more than the earlier-round investors
did. These stages aren't haphazard. A start-up usually plans
the different funding rounds right from the get-go—it hopes
to increase its valuation between funding rounds and therefore
to give up less of its equity per dollar of capital invested.
Most
VC businesses are limited partnerships, in which well-heeled
investors—large pension funds, university endowments, and
wealthy individuals—agree to invest as limited partners.
The funds are organized by experienced fund managers, also
known as general partners. These managers decide how the funds
are invested.
To use
an example we will return to, the general partners might decide
(as we did) to invest in a holographic-storage company for
several reasons. The storage market promises long-term growth.
The capacity per dollar is expected to increase by an order
of magnitude over magnetic and optical technologies. And the
risk-adjusted payoff is 10 times the initial committed capital
in an acceptable time frame. Fund managers get where they
are by demonstrating an ability to generate high returns,
based on their track records in previous funds. Typical funds
are organized for a finite life, often six or seven years,
after which the fund is required to wind down operations—and
distribute any proceeds to the limited partners.
Neither
the limited nor the general partners welcome risk. Limited
partners are looking for a higher rate of return than they
could get in the stock market but with not much more uncertainty.
And general partners are playing with other people's money.
They hope that if they consistently hit the ball well, once
in a while a home run will fly off their bats.
General
partners are compensated in two ways. First, they receive
management fees for running the fund, typically 2 percent
of funds managed. So if a general partnership is managing
a US $1 billion fund, it will receive $20 million in management
fees, as well as reimbursements.
Second,
the general partners receive a share of any profits after
the limited partners are paid back their initial investments
and their share of the profits. For example, if a $1 billion
fund returns $5 billion after management fees and expenses
are deducted, the limited partners receive their initial $1
billion plus 80 percent of $4 billion, for a total of $4.2
billion. Typically, the general partnership gets the other
20 percent of the $4 billion profit, or $800 million. This
percentage is known as the general partner "carry," which
is short for "carried interest." That's a pretty good paycheck
to divide up among, say, 10 to 20 managing directors who might
share in the carry.
And then
there are the bargains struck by the "A-list" VCs, such as
Kleiner Perkins Caufield & Byers, in Menlo Park, Calif.,
or Greylock Management Corp., in Waltham, Mass. These VCs
add substantial prestige to start-ups, so they tend to see
the hottest action. A-list VC firms get to charge more—3
percent management fees instead of 2 percent, and a 30 percent
carry instead of 20 percent. It's no wonder you see so many
Ferraris sitting in the parking lots on Menlo Park's Sand
Hill Road, home base for the VCs of Silicon Valley.